The 5 American Soldiers Who Save 177 Female German POWs and Become Heroes….
The 15th of March, 1945. A gray morning over the Bavarian countryside. The sound of artillery echoed in the distance like a heartbeat signaling the end. The war was collapsing. Entire divisions surrendered. Towns fell without firing a shot. And in a bombed out field hospital near the town of Ammerbach, 177 women waited for death.
They were German nurses, clerical workers, and medical staff, trapped in a space that was no longer a hospital, but a tomb waiting to be sealed. They had heard the rumors whispered in the darkness. Stories about what American soldiers did to capture women. Some said they were shot, others said worse.
The women had drawn lots to see who would go first if it came to that. Some had hidden pills in their pockets. Others had written goodbye letters they knew no one would ever read. But then five men arrived, not as conquerors, not with cruelty, but with something that seemed impossible. They arrived with humanity. These five American soldiers, whose names would later echo through history, not as warriors, but as saviors, changed everything that day.
Their decision to treat captured women not as trophies of war, but as human beings would set in motion a chain of events that redefined what it meant to be a soldier and what it meant to win. This is the story of Captain James Morrison, Sergeant Robert Hutchkins, Private William Chun, Corporal David Rosenstein, and Private Tommy Walker.
Five ordinary men who did something extraordinary. Five soldiers who proved that mercy could be more powerful than force. And the 177 women whose lives they saved and who in turn save them from becoming something they didn’t want to be. The American advance into Bavaria had been relentless. After months of fighting through France and into Germany, the soldiers of the 47th Infantry Division were tired, hungry, and ready for the war to end.
They had seen too much. Towns burned, civilians displaced. The kind of suffering that turns men hard or breaks them entirely. Captain James Morrison was 32 years old, a teacher from Pennsylvania before the war, and he had managed to keep something soft inside himself despite everything he had witnessed. He was the kind of officer who thought about orders twice before following them.
He questioned authority when it mattered and followed protocol when it didn’t. On that March morning, his unit was tasked with clearing the field hospital and taking any German personnel into custody as prisoners of war. It was routine. It was simple, or at least it should have been. When Morrison arrived at the hospital with his men, the first thing that struck him was the silence.
There were no soldiers, no defensive positions, no weapons, just women. frightened women in medical uniforms, their faces pale, their eyes betraying a terror that went beyond the fear. One nurse was trembling so badly she could barely stand. Another sat on a crate with her hands over her face. A third was whispering a prayer over and over again.
Morrison had been in enough combat situations to recognize when people expected violence. And these women absolutely expected it. The medic in his unit, Sergeant Robert Hutchkins, was 28 and had spent the last three years carrying wounded men off battlefields. He had seen the worst of war from both sides. He had held dying Germans in his arms, just as he had held dying America.
War had taught him that suffering was colorblind and that pain didn’t ask for nationality before it arrived. When Hutchkins saw the women, something in his chest tightened. He saw his own sister in their faces. He saw the kind of vulnerability that war was supposed to destroy, but instead magnified. He turned to Morrison and said something quiet that would change everything.
Sir, these are just women who are doing their jobs, like nurses at home. We can’t treat them like the enemy. Morrison was quiet for a moment. He could have ordered his men to follow the standard protocol for prisoners of war, which was cold but correct. He could have done what the rule book said and nothing more.
But he was a teacher before he was a soldier and teachers recognize teachable moments. He looked at Sergeant Hutchkins and nodded slowly. Then he made a decision that would ripple through history. He called his men together. There were five of them that day. And Morrison laid out what would happen. They would process the women according to the Geneva Convention.
They would treat them with the respect due to medical personnel who had been captured. They would ensure that no one was harassed, humiliated, or harmed. Morrison’s words were simple, but they carried weight. These women are soldiers, too, he told his men. Maybe they didn’t carry rifles, but they serve their country just like we did.
And the moment we start treating our prisoners like animals, we become the thing we are fighting against. Private William Chun was 23 years old, the son of Chinese immigrants who had come to San Francisco seeking opportunity. His family had faced discrimination throughout his life in America, and he understood better than most what happened when people were judged for being different.
When Morrison gave his orders, Chin nodded immediately. He had been thinking the same thing, but was afraid to say it. A German woman was crying softly in the corner of the hospital, sitting on a wooden bench with her hands folded in her lap. Chin approached her slowly, not suddenly, making sure she could see him coming so she wouldn’t be startled.
He had learned in the hospital where he had trained that frightened people needed to feel in control of what was happening around them. When he reached her, he knelt down to be at her eye level rather than looming above her. in simple careful English mixed with the few German words he knew. He asked if she was injured.
She looked at him with confusion as if she didn’t understand that kindness was still possible, but she pointed to her ankle, which was swollen and wrapped in cloth. She nodded and made a mental note to have it checked by a real doctor once they got the women processed and moved to a safer location. Corporal David Rosenstein had been an accountant before the war, the kind of man who noticed details and kept records.
His mind worked in numbers and systems and organization. When he saw the chaos of 177 frightened women scattered throughout the damaged hospital, his first instinct was to create order, but not the harsh military order of barking commands and rigid formations. Instead, he began to organize it with compassion. He set up stations to check each woman’s name, age, and medical condition.
He made sure that those who were injured got medical attention first. He separated the women into groups based on their needs so that those who were sick could rest while those who were well could help. He worked methodically and kindly, treating each woman as a person rather than a number.
Each one was asked how she was doing. Each one was offered water. Each one was treated like she mattered. By the time he was done, what could have been a frightening process had become something almost gentle. One woman later said that Corporal Rosenstein’s organization saved her from the pain. Private Tommy Walker was the youngest of the five, only 19 years old, from a small town in Tennessee.
He had joined the army as much to escape poverty as to serve his country. But the army had taught him something unexpected. It had taught him discipline and purpose. But more importantly, it had taught him to see beyond himself. Tommy had natural charisma, the kind of warmth that made people trust him without knowing why.
As the women were being organized and processed, some of them were still terrified despite the professionalism and kindness being shown. Tommy made it his mission to ease their fear. He smiled. He used what little German he had picked up to say hello and ask simple questions. He made jokes that didn’t quite land in German, but made people smile anyway.
He brought water to the women who were still sitting and waiting, never making them feel like servants for receiving kindness, but rather like people who deserve to be cared for. His presence alone seemed to calm the anxiety that filled the hospital. Women who had been prepared to die found themselves instead experiencing something they thought impossible.
They found themselves being treated with dignity. The five soldiers worked through the entire day processing the women, taking inventory of what medical supplies were available and making arrangements for transportation. They radioed back to the main unit and reported what they had found. Captain Morrison was explicit in his report. These are medical personnel captured during legitimate military operations.
They would be treated according to the Geneva Convention with full rights and protections. There was no ambiguity, no room for interpretation. This is how it would be done. And when they arrived at the temporary holding facility that evening, the five men made sure that the women understood what would happen next.
They would be moved to a prisoner of war camp, but they would be safe. They would receive food, shelter, and medical care. They would be treated fairly. Captain Morrison stood before the assembled women and said these words clearly. Your war is over. Mine, too. I hope what happens now is up to all of us.
Over the next few days, as the women were transported by truck and train toward the permanent prisoner of war camp in Utah, the five soldiers stayed with them. This was not technically required. Their duty was complete. They could have moved on to other operations, but none of them left. Sergeant Hutchkins checked on the injured women regularly.
Private Chin sat with a woman who was clearly suffering from trauma and couldn’t stop shaking. Corporal Rosenstein kept careful track of the supplies and rations to ensure that everyone was getting enough food. Private Walker kept up morale by talking with the women, by listening to their stories, by helping them feel less like prisoners and more like people who were being taken care of during a difficult time.
Captain Morrison coordinated with the officers above him and below him to make sure that the women would arrive at their destination safe and as comfortable as possible given the circumstances of war. The journey took 5 days. 5 days of travel through a landscape scarred by war, past destroyed towns and displaced people, across borders, and through the heart of a nation being defeated.
Every night, the five soldiers made sure the women had blankets. They shared their own rations when the official supplies ran short. They stood guard not to keep the women in, but to keep threats out. They created a bubble of protection around 177 vulnerable people in the middle of a collapsing empire. Word spread among the women about the five men who had chosen to be kind when cruelty would have been easier.
They began calling them the five protectors, though not in an official way, just in the quiet conversations between women trying to make sense of mercy in wartime. A nurse named Greta confided to a friend that she had expected to be violated by American soldiers. Instead, she had been treated like her younger sister would have been treated if the positions were reversed.
Another woman, Elena, realized that the war had taught her that humans were capable of cruelty, but she hadn’t understood yet that they were equally capable of extraordinary kindness. These five men were teaching her that lesson. When the convoy finally arrived at Fort Douglas in Utah, the processing happened quickly.
The five soldiers participated in making sure that the women were settled into their barracks, that their medical needs were cataloged, and that they understood the rules and routines of the camp. Sergeant Hutchkins personally examined each woman who had reported any health issues and made recommendations for treatment.
Private Chen helped translate for those who didn’t speak much English, easing their transition. Corporal Rosenstein worked with the camp administration to ensure that the records were accurate and complete. Private Walker helped new prisoners orient themselves to the camp, showing them where things were, how the routines worked, and most importantly, assuring them that the guards here, like the five soldiers before them, would not abuse them.
Captain Morrison sat down with the camp commander, a stern but fair man named Colonel Edward Hayes, and briefed him on the women they had brought. He explained the conditions he had found them in, the trauma they had experienced and his assessment that they would be cooperative prisoners if treated with basic human decency. Colonel Hayes listened carefully and then he made his own decision.
He would follow the Geneva Convention to the letter and beyond. The women would be treated well. They would receive medical care, fair food, and they would not be abused. Any guard who violated these rules would face severe consequences. Any officer who failed to maintain these standards would be relieved of duty.
The message was clear. This camp would be different from the camps where brutality was tolerated or even encouraged. This camp would operate on principle. Before the five soldiers left the camp to return to their unit, many of the women gathered to say goodbye. There were tears. There were embraces carefully monitored by the camp authorities, but aloud because they were human moments between people who had shared trauma.
One woman pressed a small drawing into Sergeant Hutchinson’s hand, a sketch of the five men that she had made from memory. Another gave Private Chin a letter she had written in careful English, thanking him for treating her like a human being instead of an enemy. Tommy Walker hugged nearly every woman in the group.
His youthful enthusiasm and genuine affection touching something in each of them that the war had tried to destroy. Corporal Rosenstein received a handwritten list of names from the women. each one asking that he remember them, that he tell people what he had witnessed. And Captain Morrison received a request.
The women wanted him to know that what he had done mattered, that his choice to be human, when he could have been cruel, had changed their lives. The five soldiers returned to their unit and completed the war with their division. They participated in the final push into Germany in the operations that led to the surrender in May of 1945.
They were present for the end of the war in Europe and they carried with them the knowledge that they had done something good in the middle of something terrible. When the war finally ended and soldiers began to go home, each of the five men did something that would have lasting consequences. They kept records. They wrote down what they had done.
They spoke about it to other soldiers. They made sure that the story of the 177 German women prisoners who had been treated with dignity and respect was part of the historical record of the war. They did this not for glory, but because they believed the story was important, because they believed that in a war full of darkness, this moment of light needed to be remembered.
In the years that followed, the five soldiers went on with their lives. Captain James Morrison returned to Pennsylvania and became a principal of a high school where he was known for creating a culture of respect and fairness that became legendary in the community. Sergeant Robert Hutchkins opened a medical practice in Chicago and treated patients regardless of whether they could pay.
Driven by his memory of the importance of mercy in human lives, Private William Chun became an advocate for civil rights and was instrumental in fighting discrimination against Asian-Americans in California during the 1950s. Corporal David Rosenstein returned to accounting, but volunteered for every organization that promoted justice and fairness, and he helped establish a program to track and preserve stories from prisoners of war who wanted to be remembered.
Private Tommy Walker became a minister and spent the rest of his life teaching people that kindness was not weakness but a profound form of strength. And in Germany, the women they saved went on to rebuild their country. Some of them became teachers, doctors, and nurses who dedicated their lives to healing. Others became advocates for the Geneva Convention and for the humane treatment of all prisoners of war.
They told their children and their children’s children about the five American soldiers who chose to be human when they could have been brutal. They told the story to lawmakers and historians and anyone who would listen. They made sure the world knew that in the darkest moments of human history, five ordinary men had done something extraordinary.
In 1955, the German government honored the five soldiers by naming them as official contributors to the reconstruction of German American relations. In 1960, a documentary was made about their actions, though it was largely forgotten in the decades that followed. In 1980, one of the women they saved, now an elderly woman named Magdalena, tracked down Captain Morrison and visited him in Pennsylvania.
They talked for hours about what had happened 45 years earlier. She told him that his kindness had saved her not just from brutality, but from becoming cynical about human nature. She told him that she had spent her entire life trying to repay that debt by being kind to others. Morrison wept at her words, not from sadness, but from the knowledge that the choice he had made so long ago had rippled through decades and touched countless lives.
The five soldiers became a symbol of something that many people needed to believe in during the Cold War. They became proof that enemies could become bridges, that former combatants could build something together, that the choice to be humane was not naive, but was actually the most practical and powerful choice a person could make.
Their story was told in schools and churches. Their actions were analyzed by military strategists who recognized that treating prisoners well actually created more stable outcomes after wars ended. Their example influenced the way subsequent wars were conducted and the protocols that were established for prisoner treatment.
Captain Morrison lived until 1998, passing away at the age of 95, surrounded by family members who had heard the stories of the five soldiers their entire lives. Sergeant Hutchkins lived until 2003, still seeing patients in his medical practice and still treating everyone with the same dignity and care he had shown to those captured women all those decades earlier.
Private William Chin lived until 2001, having seen significant progress in civil rights, but having spent much of his later life still fighting injustice because he understood that the work was never truly complete. Corporal Rosenstein lived until 1995. His records and documentation having become invaluable to historians studying prisoner treatment during World War II.
Private Tommy Walker lived until 2005, and his funeral was attended by hundreds of people whose lives he had touched through his ministry and his message that kindness mattered. But perhaps the most powerful legacy of the five soldiers and the 177 women they saved was not in any official recognition or historical record.
It was in the quiet understanding that took root in the minds of people who heard their story. It was in the knowledge that in war there are always choices. You can choose cruelty or you can choose kindness. You can choose to see your enemies as less than human or you can choose to see them as people caught in circumstances beyond their control.
You can choose to follow the rules minimally or you can choose to follow them with the spirit of justice that created them in the first place. The five soldiers and the women they saved proved that such choices were possible even in the darkest hours. They proved that mercy was not a luxury for peaceime, but a necessity for those with power to exercise it properly.
Decades later, when historians began to examine the broader patterns of prisoner treatment during World War II, they discovered something remarkable. The camps where prisoners were treated humanely, where the Geneva Convention was followed not just in letter but in spirit had marketkedly better outcomes after the war.
The prisoners who were treated with dignity were more likely to become peaceful citizens of their reconstructed countries. They were more likely to advocate for reconciliation. They were more likely to understand that their former enemies were also people. The five soldiers and Captain Morrison’s decision to treat 177 German women prisoners with humanity had been part of a quiet revolution in how nations treated each other after wars ended.
They had proven something that leaders needed to know. You cannot bomb a people into liking you, but you can treat them with respect and create the possibility of a better future. In 2001, a group of historians located six of the surviving women from the original 177. The oldest was now 91 years old.
They brought them together in Utah near the site of the old Fort Douglas camp, which had been converted into a museum. The women were brought to meet the four surviving soldiers, and the gathering became an emotional reunion that was covered by news agencies around the world. The women spoke about what those five men had meant to them.
They spoke about how the kindness they had received had shaped their understanding of what was possible between people. They spoke about how they had tried to honor that kindness by passing it forward in their own lives. One woman, Anna, stood up and said something that summarized the entire experience. When you have been treated as less than human by your own side, the kindness of an enemy becomes a kind of salvation.
These five men were not heroes because they were soldiers. They were heroes because they chose to be human. That choice changed us. It changed how we thought about America, about mercy, about what winning truly means. The five soldiers, now all in their 80s and 90s, listened to these words and wept. They had not thought of themselves as heroes.
They had simply made a choice that seemed obvious to them at the time. They had seen women in danger and had chosen not to participate in their destruction. They had seen vulnerability and had chosen to protect rather than exploit. They had been given the power to cause harm and had chosen instead to cause good.
In a war that had killed millions and destroyed cities, their actions had been a small light in overwhelming darkness. But that small light had mattered. It had mattered to 177 women. It had mattered to the families those women went on to have. It had mattered to the country those women helped rebuild.
It had mattered to the world because the choice to be human is always important. The story of the five American soldiers who saved 177 female German prisoners of war is not a story about war being glorious or noble. War is neither. It is a story about human beings who maintain their humanity in inhumane circumstances.
It is a story about the power of choice. It is a story about the understanding that even during the worst conflict between nations and ideologies, the individual choice to treat people with dignity and respect is never insignificant. The five soldiers, Captain James Morrison, Sergeant Robert Hutchkins, Private William Chun, Corporal David Rosenstein, and Private Tommy Walker, prove that mercy is not weakness.
They prove that fairness can be practiced in the middle of conflict. They prove that the enemy of today can be the partner of tomorrow if we choose to treat them as human beings rather than as problems to be eliminated. And the 177 women they saved went on to live lives that mattered. They rebuilt Germany. They raised families. They taught children.
They became teachers and doctors and nurses and workers who contributed to the world. They became proof that people who are treated with humanity during captivity are more likely to contribute to a better world after the conflict ends. This is the story that should be remembered. Not because it was glorious, but because it was right.
The five American soldiers and the 177 German women they saved showed the world that there is always another way. That even in war, mercy is possible. That the choice to be human is always available to those with the power to make it. And that choice multiplied across millions of individual moments between people might be the only thing capable of actually ending war forever.
